First impressions and second thoughts

The latest issue of The New Winawer Report has now been posted.

The New Winawer Report, issue 20This one concerns the new main line of the Poisoned Pawn, where Black plays … dxc3 instead of … Bd7, and follows with 12. … d4 (diagram). Theory knew of this as far back as 1957, based on the game Kots-Ilivitsky, USSR Championship ½-final, Sverdlovsk 1957, but it did not catch on. But why not? It’s easy to dismiss such anomalies with a shrug and a comment on “the vagaries of fashion”, but I argue it’s worth making a more searching enquiry about what was missed earlier and why.

Apart from such speculations, the issue has a new game that’s missing from all the databases, as far as I can tell, but that pre-dates all known games in this line. It’s even quite a nice win for Black. See Procter-Knibbs, Postal Chess Club All-play-all 1E, 1949.

Posted in Articles | Leave a comment

Myles na gCopaleen

The last post mentioned that Gerry O’Nolan, member of Dublin C.C. for fifty years, was a brother of the journalist/author Brian O’Nolan, better known as Myles na gCopaleen or Flann O’Brien. As Flann O’Brien he wrote several celebrated novels: At Swim-Two-Birds, The Third Policeman, and The Dalkey Archive. As Myles na gCopaleen he had a long-running column in the Irish Times, Cruiskeen Lawn, a strange mixture of satire and fantasy covering a wide range of stock characters and topics.

He doesn’t seem to have played chess seriously: J. J. Walsh recalls playing one or two offhand games with him, but that’s about it. However chess crops up occasionally in Cruiskeen Lawn. Here is one example. It’s taken from the Irish Times of Saturday, March 25, 1944. And from an actual copy of the newspaper, mind you, which I bought in San Francisco a couple of years ago. It bears the stamp “Office of Strategic Services”: that’s the precursor to the CIA. I wonder what they made of Myles na gCopaleen.

Anyway, on p. 3 we have:

CRUISKEEN LAWN
By Myles na gCopaleen

It has been brought to my attention that an unfortunate misprint occurred in the notation of my chess game with Capablanca, recorded in this column a few weeks ago. I give the game again and thank the many anxious souls who have written to me on the matter, wrung up, sent telegrams, and called personally.

White— Black—
M. na gC. Capablanca
1.   P-K4 P-QKt3
2.   B-B4 B-Kt2
3.   P-Q3 P-KB4
4.   P x P B x P
5.   Q-R5 ch. P-Kt3
6.   P x P Kt-KB3
7.   B-7 mate

I would again counsel all serious students of the game to study this great game and commit it to memory. It is among the finer things done in the masterplay of yesterday.

That’s followed by a Keats and Chapman item that I’ve seen in anthologies: “On one occasion he [Chapman] dreamt that he had died and gone to heaven”, if you’re familiar with the genre.

[Click to replay the full game!]

Posted in Players | 4 Comments

Gerry O’Nolan

The ICU web site has a recent post discussing the history of Dublin C.C.. The major work on this is of course the outstanding history compiled by Dr. A. A. Luce around 1967, at the time of the club’s centenary. This is now available on the Dublin C.C. web site, and is highly recommended if you haven’t seen it before.

I wasn’t aware until I saw the ICU post, though, that there is an additional document on Dublin C.C.’s site, covering the club history from 1967 to the present day, compiled by Denis Dempsey, very much in the same style as Dr. Luce’s booklet and also highly recommended.

One of the players mentioned in the update is Gerry O’Nolan, a member of the club from (approximately) 1934 to his death in 1984. Though the update doesn’t mention it, I understand he was a brother of Brian O’Nolan, a.k.a. Myles na gCopaleen, a.k.a. Flann O’Brien, the celebrated journalist/author.

The ICU games archive has none of his games, and I have never seen any anywhere else either. However we can now rectify this gap with two games, both of which featured O’Nolan with the Black pieces against J. J. Walsh. Both games are from a scorebook of 100 of J. J. Walsh’s games from 1949 to 1961, which J. J. has kindly lent me.

In Walsh-O’Nolan, Club tournament 1951, Black dropped a pawn early in the opening and White had no difficulties converting. (It’s not clear which club this was. J. J. switched from Eogahn Ruadh to Clontarf in 1951, and did not join Dublin until 1957.)

Walsh-O'Nolan, Leinster ch 1954The second game is from the 1954 Leinster championship, the first of two occasions on which J. J. won the championship. In round 5, a Trompowsky led to the diagrammed position with Black to move. J. J.’s notes point out that 13 … 0-0 loses quickly to 14. Bxd6 Bxd6 15. e5 Be7 16. Rh3, while 13. … 0-0-0 is met by 14. b4 with an attack. In the game, O’Nolan tried 13. … g5, but after 14. Bxd6 Bxd6 15. e5 Be7 16. Rh3 Qg4 17. Rh6 with h3 to follow, the black queen had to be given up.

Does anyone know of any other games of Gerry O’Nolan, and in particular any wins?

Posted in Games, Players | 2 Comments

An Armstrong Cup record?

In the last post I mentioned that the 1984-85 season has been up to now one of the most mysterious of all Armstrong seasons. David McAlister’s full roll of honour at irishchesshistory.com contains only the name of Dundrum as the winning team—and even there his only source was myself. I played on that team but had only the haziest of recollections of the season. No reports appeared in Fiacla Fichille, and none in the Irish Times either. Even J.J. Walsh’s scorebooks, an invaluable resource for virtually any other season from 1951 to his retirement, showed nothing for 1984-85: he seems to have taken a break from the game for that one season.

So it was quite a find when John Gibson produced the full set of player cards for that season. With these, the full winning team in board order, and including everyone who played any games that season, was Seán Coffey, Kevin McHugh, John Griffin, Eric McMahon, Brian MacRéamoinn, Brendan Lyons, David Drakeford (capt.), Ivan Gormally, and Paul Fallon.

Our captain David Drakeford had a particularly good season. Here’s his player card:

David Drakeford Armstrong Cup record 1985

So that’s 10/10. Furthermore, this was in the brief era when the Armstrong was held in two stages: two qualifying groups of six teams, followed by a championship section of six teams and a relegation section of six teams. The championship section thus formed a sort of ‘super-Armstrong’ and made very high scores even harder to achieve.

10/10 scores in the Armstrong must be rare. But there’s another unusual aspect to the team’s record, for which David as captain deserves credit: the winning squad used a total of 9 players all season, and even then the reserve Paul Fallon played only two games. And in addition the team conceded no walkovers or defaults. This must also be a candidate for an all-time record for the Armstrong.

Posted in Armstrong Cup, Players | 4 Comments

Ivan Gormally c. 1962-2013

Early this year I heard the sad news of the very untimely passing of Ivan Gormally. He was a clubmate of mine from our very earliest days at Dundrum C.C. and would have been a couple of years older than me.

He was one of the Dundrum team that played MTK Budapest in the European Club Championship in 1985, as previously recounted here. Dundrum had qualified by winning the Armstrong Cup in 1984-85, for the first and only time, but I couldn’t recall whether Ivan had played on the Armstrong team. And that particular season is one of the most mysterious of all Armstrong seasons, with essentially no records previously available. Furthermore the ICU games archive had none of his games.

During my last trip to Dublin, however, I visited John Gibson, who turns out to have a treasure trove of records. One item is the complete set of player records from the 1984-85 Armstrong season. From this it is clear not only that Ivan played, he was a key factor in Dundrum’s victory, with a score of 7/9, mostly on board 8:

Ivan Gormally Armstrong Cup record 1984-85

As for games, one fortuitously showed up. Oliver Dunne showed me the tournament booklet for the 1981 Irish championship. At the back there are selected games from the supporting events, including the decisive last round game in the Irish intermediate championship (1500-1900), annotated by the winner of the game and the event.

Gormally-A. Delaney, Irish intermdiate championship 1981Ivan was White against Ann Delaney, and in response to 15 … Qc7-e7? he has just played 16. Nh4-f5. After 16. … gxf5 17. Qxh5 Qg5 18. Qxg5 hxg5 19. exf5 Bxf5 20. Ne4 Black had either to lose a pawn or make the concession 20. … Bxe4 21. Bxe4 when Black has no counterplay and suffers major weaknesses on the light squares. Ivan managed to convert his advantage without further problems. [Click to replay the full game.] Final scores: 1. Ivan Gormally; 2-4. “Dillon, Hassan, Thomson” [no first names given; probably Andrew Thomson?] 5/6; 69 played.

Posted in Games, Players | 2 Comments

B. E. A. Cup 1975-76

The Elm Mount team that won the B. E. A. Cup in 1975-76, with trophy:

ElmMount_BEA_197576

This is from a Facebook post by one of the players, for which thanks.

How many of the players can you identify?

You might like to compare with the picture of the Elm Mount Branagan Cup-winning team this year, for one of them!

[Update, August 30, 2014:] the photo was of course from Gerry MacElligott’s Facebook page, and he supplies the names in a comment below: left to right Ken Clarke, Seán Kennelly, Gerard MacElligott, Alan MacDonagh, Alek Tyrrell, unknown. Not pictured: Gerry K. Barry.

If I understand correctly, three of that team will be playing, still for Elm Mount, in the Armstrong Cup this season.

Posted in B. E. A. Cup, Photos | 2 Comments

Winawer Praxis—III

The latest issue of The New Winawer Report has been posted (and not before time!). This one again covers some recent games in theoretical lines. This time the games are taken from this year’s Irish championship, which featured a feast of Winawers. Four games featured 6. … Ne7 7. Qg4 alone, and there was another with 6. … Qc7 7. Qg4.

Murray-Brady, irish Ch 2014Murray-Brady from round 7 featured a novelty in a topical line. The diagram shows the position after 19. Qf2xa7 Nf5-h4!?. Previously 19. Qxa7 had never been played, but it was analysed by Berg in his recent book; Black can take a draw with 19. …Rxg2 or accept a slightly worse position after 19. … Bc6. After 19. … Nh4!? Black quickly built up a winning position. Of course it can’t be that easy, but where could White have improved and what is the evaluation with best play?

This issue considers the question, along with O’Connor-Ó Cinnéide from round 8, which delved into a long theoretical line in the 7. … 0-0 variation that has been under a cloud lately from Black’s perspective.

Posted in Articles, Games | 1 Comment

B. E. A. Cup

The recent posts about the Branagan Cup reminded me that there are many other competitions that we haven’t gotten around to covering here yet. At the final day of the Leinster Leagues this year, I was taken aback when I was asked if the intention was to cover the top competitions only: nothing could be further from the truth!

A new page has been added for the B. E. A. Cup, division 5 of the Leinster Leagues. This dates back to 1972:

“The British European Airways perpetual chess challenge cup was presented to the Leinster Chess Union at a reception in the Collegians’ clubrooms, Donnybrook, last night, by Mr. James Dunne, chief sales representative of B.E.A.

… The BEA Cup has an entry of 26 teams and play in this contest will continue until March.”
Irish Times (Thursday) November 23, 1972, p. 5.

That’s quite an initial entry list! Of course this was immediately after the Fischer-Spassky match and at the all-time height of chess interest in Ireland. (The Branagan Cup dates to the same era: its first round was held on February 14, 1973, with a similarly huge entry, though that first competition didn’t finish until 1974.)

Though I never played in the B. E. A. Cup myself, I do have a connection, as my father played in it. From the Irish Times (Wednesday) November 13, 1974, p. 4, a third-round match in the B. E. A. Cup (Central), played at St. George’s Quay:

Caissa “B” E. S. B.
D. Doyle adj. G. Meeghan
J. Power 0 – 1 A. Higgins
B. Doyle ½ – ½ E. Clancy
J. Burke 1 – 0 C. Kavanagh
J. Bowes 1 – 0 J. McCarthy
P. Guiney 0 – 1 K. Coffey
2½ – 2½
Posted in B. E. A. Cup | 1 Comment

Branagan Cup 1977

David McAlister has provided a huge amount of new information on the Branagan Cup page, and we’re now down to just seven seasons where we’re not sure of the winners. There are also many more details of winning teams and matches.

One discrepancy that showed up concerns the 1977 final between Dundrum and Dublin, previously covered here (DisinformatorTM, Dec 24, 2011) based on Seán Terry’s stirring account of the deciding game. That account had Dundrum winning on board count. But David found reports in the Irish Times and Irish Press indicating that Dundrum actually won 3½-2½ and that the deciding Terry-Frain game was played on board 4 rather than board 6 (though they differ slightly on board order).

Further corroborating information comes from J.J. Walsh’s scorebook, which gives the scorecard along with his game against Eugene Curtin (a short draw).

The full scorecard therefore seems most likely to be (as David gave):

Dundrum Dublin
T. Harding ½ – ½ A. Spillane
E. Curtin ½ – ½ J. J. Walsh
J. Griffin 0 – 1 J. Brennan
J. Frain ½ – ½ S. Terry
J. Prendiville 1 – 0 G. Gaden
G. McDonagh 1 – 0 J. W. Hackett
3½ – 2½

So Terry-Frain was indeed the crucial game: had Seán won, Dublin would have won on board count.

There are similarities with this year’s final: the winners achieved their victory by sweeping the lower boards.

Posted in Branagan Cups, Games, Tournaments | 1 Comment

Branagan Cup final 2014: Elm Mount 3½ – 2½ Gonzaga

Congratulations to Elm Mount (and commiserations to Gonzaga) on winning the Branagan Cup for the fourth year in succession (and the fourth year in all).

Elm Mount team with Branagan Cup, July 2014

From Gerry MacElligott’s Facebook page (and with permission, for which thanks) we have a picture of the winning team, with cup.

Back row, l. to r.: Matthias Rahneberg, Zygis Jakubauskas, David Fitzsimons.
Front row, l. to r.: Liam Porter, Gerard MacElligott, Ciarán Quinn, Oliver Dunne.
(I think—corrections welcome.)

[Update, August 30, 2014: Not pictured: Bernard Boyle, Adam Spirek.]

The scorecard for the final (provided by Oliver Dunne, for which thanks also) is:

Elm Mount Gonzaga
D. Fitzsimons 0 – 1 S. Collins
Z. Jakubauskas ½ – ½ K. Delaney
C. Quinn 0 – 1 C. O’Donnell
M. Rahneberg 1 – 0 D. Murray
G. MacElligott 1 – 0 P. J. Hayes
O. Dunne 1 – 0 J. McMorrow
3½ – 2½

Board 6 was the last to finish. Elm Mount needed a win, as a draw would see Gonzaga win on tie-break (board count?). When John McMorrow resigned, he had 9 seconds on the clock to Oliver’s 2 min., 38 seconds. Dramatic stuff!

Games will be added if and when they become available.

Posted in Branagan Cups, Photos, Tournaments | 1 Comment