Pye – Kernan, Leinster Senior Schoolboys’ Championship 1972

Many thanks to Robert Pye, who answered the question from the previous past on what the final outcome was in the Leinster Senior Schoolboys’ Championship (essentially the Leinster U19 championship) in 1972: the players shared the title after they had each won one game in a playoff match (see comment on last post). This was the first shared title.

The event itself was held at St. Joseph’s School for the Blind from December 28, 1971 to January 3, 1972. Eleven players entered, and Pye and Kernan finished joint first on 5½/6, dropping only a half point against each other.

Their game, in round 3, appeared in Paul Cassidy’s column in the Irish Independent on January 7. As of the date of this post, it does not appear in the ICU games archive.

Pye - Kernan, Leinster Schools 1972
Pye – Kernan, Leinster Senior Schoolboys’ Championship 1972 (3)
10. ?

The diagram shows the position facing Pye at move 10. On the previous move, he had inadvisedly captured on d5 (9. d4, with an equal game, was better).

The game continued 10. d4 exf3 (better 10… Bd6 11. Ne5 cxd5, when Black stands considerably better) 11. dxc5 fxg2 (here 11… Qg6! retained some advantage) 12. Re1, when Black’s advantage had disspiated.

[Click to replay the full game.]

Posted in Games | Leave a comment

Leinster Schools Championships

The Leinster Junior Championships for 2023 begin tomorrow in Stillorgan. Best of luck to all participants!

The competition started in 1942, with only a single section, and limited to boys. The Leinster Schoolboys’ Championship quickly became the Leinster Senior Schoolboys’ Championship, later the Leinster Schools’ Championship, and finally the Leinster U19 Championship.

An incomplete list of winners (of the top section) is available on the Tournament Series page here. (Many thanks to David McAlister, who provided several winners I had missed.) The list covers 63 out of the 80 possible championships (there was no championship in 2021; it’s not clear if a championship was held in every other year from 1942 to 2022 inclusive).

For some years, the results of the championship event are available, but the destination of the title is unknown. For example, in 1972 Bernard Kernan and Robert Pye tied, and a playoff match was planned, but no reports seem to be available on the final outcome. (Was the title shared?) Similarly, in 2018 Jacob Flynn and Alice O’Gorman tied, but reports do not make clear how the title was decided.

I assume the trophy will be available at the competition this week. If anyone reading this is there, and can check the trophy for the missing winners, I’d be very grateful for the information.

Posted in Tournaments | 1 Comment

Irish championship players

The lists of Irish championship players have been updated to reflect the 2022 championship, and to correct some errors and add details.

Five players made their débuts in 2022, taking the total to 575 players in all, including 561 men and 14 women [but see update below]. Of these, 50 have been Irish champion.

The players who made their début in 2022 were Andrey Ivanov, Cathal Keenan, Jason Liu, Diana Mats, and Oisín O’Cuilleanain.

The first names of Hubert Boyd and Herbert Quinton were corrected, and the rendering of Donal Déiseach’s name was modified.

First names have been added for Kevin Burke (2021) (previously omitted due to a glitch), Colm Darby (1989), M. P. (Michael Philip) Furmston (1963), Shane Heffernan (1993), Maurice Hughes (1962), David Kerr (1962), W. D. (William David) Kerr (1948), Alexander Martin (1950, 1951), Dominic Mockler (1957), Derek O’Byrne (1985), Peter Ryan (1992), and Dave Smith (1981, 1982, 1983, 1985). An extra initial was added for J. A. Long (1962).

Update, December 19, 2022: The lists have been updated to distinguish between the Michael O’Brien who played in 1967 (now Michael O’Brien (of Limerick)) and the Michael O’Brien who played in six championships between 1980 and 1992 (now Michael O’Brien (of Cork)); many thanks to Jack Killane, who suggested there was an issue here. With that change, there are 576 players in all, including 562 men and 14 women. In addition, David Houston’s name (previously with typo) has been corrected, and Gearóidín Uí Laighléis’ first name has been added (previously omitted due to a glitch). First names have been added for the five players who made their début in 2022. In addition, first names have been added for Colm Kenny (1967), Victor Lyons (1967), and Peter O’Kane (1968).

The full list is available in alphabetical order and in descending order of number of championships played.

Posted in Irish championships, Players | Leave a comment

P. Lalić – Wall, Thames Valley League Knockout Cup 2022-23

I was alerted by Twitter to an interesting game earlier this week involving Gavin Wall, which comes with an even more interesting annotation. The game was against Peter Lalić in a club knockout match in London, and the annotation is by John Saunders, associate editor of CHESS magazine and founder of the BritBase archive.

The full annotation is given at Kingston C.C.’s web site; it includes some discussion of the difference between the best engine moves and the best human moves, with application to this game.

The game, without any of the notes, has been added to the archive here.

 P. Lalic - Wall, London 2022
P. Lalić – Wall, Thames Valley League Knockout Cup 2022-23
17… ?

In the diagrammed position, it’s Gavin Wall to play. How should he continue?

Posted in Games | Leave a comment

Basman – Walsh, Hastings Challengers Reserves A 1963-64

John Saunders posted a report on Hastings 1963-64 at BritBase, and I was interested to note that J. J. Walsh had finished second in the Challengers Reserves A ‘Pelton’, behind Michael Basman.

The report had none of J. J.’s games. A quick search in the normal places failed to turn up anything, but by sheer coincidence I saw the game against Basman very shortly afterwards in the Irish Chess Journal.

The 17-year-old Basman had a slight advantage out of the opening, but then erred badly, and was lost as early as move 12. Thereafter it was all simply a matter of time, and the game ended much later with the diagrammed picturesque position.

Basman - Walsh, Hastings Challengers Reserves A (Pelton) 1963-64
Basman – Walsh, Hastings Challengers Reserves ‘A’ (Pelton) 1963-64 (4)
Final position

[Click to replay the full game.]

J. J. won his first five games, of which this was the fourth, and still was in the clear lead heading into the last round. Unfortunately a loss allowed Basman to leapfrog his way to first.

I prepared the game and was about to send it to John Saunders this morning, when I found that it had already been added earlier today, sent by regular contributor Ulrich Tamm, who found it in J. J.’s From My Games. You have to move quickly in these matters!

Posted in Games | 1 Comment

A four queens game: Fitzsimons – Rowson, London 2022

The Mindsports Masters GM Norm event in London in September produced the following interesting position early on:

Fitzsimons - Rowson, London 2022
Fitzsimons – Rowson, Mindsports Masters GM 2022
46. ?

If you would like to treat this as a (not too easy) puzzle, please don’t read further.

David Fitzsimons now erred with 46. Qb8+?. The right way is 46. a7!, which wins after 47… e2 48. a8=Q+ Kh7 49. Nf7!, e.g., 49… e1=Q (else White can prevent this promotion) 50. Qh8+ Kg6 51. Rg4+ and White mates in a few more moves.

After the game’s 46… Kh7 47. a7 e2, 48. a1=Q? was another error, and after 48… e1=Q, White was lost. More often than not, the side promoting first wins in these four queens games, but here White runs out of checks quickly.

Instead, there was still a (difficult) draw to be had via 48. Nf7!!. The rook capture loses, while the queen capture and the immediate promotion only draw.

[Click to replay the full game.]

Why does this startling knight move work? One hint lies in the fact that the position after the game’s 48… e1=Q, easily won for Black, would instead be convincingly won for White if only the knight were not on the board. After 49. Qg8+ Kg6, White’s 50. Qxc6 would be a devastating check if it were not for the knight. Thus 49. Nf7 is (partly) a line-opening sacrifice.

Posted in Games | Leave a comment

W. Desmond Taylor 1941-2022

I was sorry to hear of the death of one of Ireland’s most distinguished correspondence players, Desmond Taylor, in August, aged 80. He earned the correspondence chess International Master title in 1998 and the correspondence chess Senior International Master title in 2002.

The Lisburn C.C. Facebook page had a post on October 24, with the news, plus some details of his life and chess career, including a recent photograph.

One of his most notable wins was against Tõnu Õim of Estonia, twice World Correspondence Chess Champion (1977-1983 and 1994-2000), during the preliminary round of the 13th Correspondence Chess Olympiad in 1998. His annotation of the game appears on the ICCA web pages. A crucial moment is shown in the diagrammed position:

Oim - Taylor, CCOL13 S3 B1 1998
Õim – Taylor, Correspondence Chess Olympiad 13, Section 3, Board 1, 1998
16. ?

Topalov had suggested 16. Nbc7 Bxd5! 17. Nxd5 Rfe8 here, in notes on the game Adams – Topalov, Wijk aan Zee 1996. Õim instead played the novelty 16. Ndc7, presumably to avoid this possibility, but it did not work out, and Taylor took control and won well.

Intriguingly, the ICCA notes say “In Tallinn shortly after this game ended, the world champion told Tim Harding he would never had played this move had he owned a computer to check it.” The game of correspondence chess has changed out of all recognition.

[Click to replay the full game.]

Posted in Games, Players | Leave a comment

Ulster Masters 2022

The Ulster Masters took place last weekend, in Lisburn C.C.’s new premises, attracting 40 players across two sections. The top section was won by Peter Carroll, for the second year in a row. A full report has been added here.

An unusual ending cropped up in the round two game between David Hill (Strand) and Stephen Scannell (Lisburn). Hill, though heavily outrated, had earlier been three pawns up, but missed several opportunities to close the game out. Finally the game simplified to the diagrammed position. Knight plus two pawns versus knight is normally easily winning. This position is winning, but it turns out to be very tricky indeed, with themes of mutual zugzwang. It’s not easy to understand what’s going on, even with the aid of the Nalimov tablebases; I would find it impossible without them.

Hill - Scannell, Ulster Masters 2022
Hill – Scannell, Ulster Masters 2022
54. ?

White now played the natural 54. Kg2?, but it turns out that this should throw away the win. According to the tablebases, 54. Kg1! and 54. Nc5 are the only moves that win.

Scannell erred in turn with 54… Ke5? (only 54… Kf5 and 54… Ng5 draw). After the further 55. Kf2 Ng5 56. Nc5 Kf5 57. Kg2, a mutual zugzwang position was reached.

There followed 57… Kg4 58. e4, again a mutual zugzwang, 58… Nf3, and now White made the final error with 59. Nd7?, letting the win slip: 59. Nd3! is the only move that wins (though this is still far from obvious). Best play then goes 59… Nd2 60. Nf2+! (only move) Kg5 60. Kh2 Nc4 61. Kh3 Ne3 62. Nd3 Kh5 63. Ne5 Kg5 64. Kh2 Kf6 65. Nf3, and White has consolidated.

[Click to replay the full game.]

Posted in Tournaments, Ulster Masters | Leave a comment

Basman – Tr. Kanyamarala, 1st EJCOA Invitational 2021

Michael Basman played some tournaments last year, including the 1st EJCOA Forest Hall Invitational in Northumbria, England, a 10-player all-play-all in which Tarun Kanyamarala earned his first IM norm. The 75-year-old Basman scored 2½/9. A photo of round 7 shows him on the far board.

He scored 0/3 against Irish players. His first round loss against David Fitzsimons saw him lost out of the opening, but he should have drawn his second round game against Tarun Kanyamarala (which commenced 1. b4 e5 2. a3). By far the most interesting of these games, though, was his fourth round game against Trisha Kanyamarala, a game he could have won.

This one opened with the Grob, 1. g4.

Basman - Tr. Kanyamarala, 1st EJCOA Invitational 2022
Basman – Tr. Kanyamarala, 1st EJCOA Invitational 2022
Position after 25… Qe7

The position after move 25 was no advertisement for this eccentric opening. White has two bad bishops, and two bad knights; the one on h3 has particularly poor prospects. Or so it seems.

Basman - Tr. Kanyamarala, 1st EJCOA Invitational 2022, 35W
Same game
35. ?

Nine moves later, the second diagram was reached. Now Basman could have won with the shot 35. Ng6+!! hxg6 36. Qb4, since 36… Bf6 37. hxg6+ Kg8 38. Qf4 is crushing. The change in fortunes for the formerly forlorn knight is startling. (The more prosaic 35. Qb4 also wins; the difference is that it allows the extra defence 35… Rxf4.)

The game’s 35. Qc1? was thus a missed opportunity, but Basman was still slightly better, and (after some further twists and turns) was still equal ten moves later, when he blundered a piece, ultimately losing.

[Click to replay the full game.]

Posted in Games | Leave a comment

Michael Basman 1946-2022

I was sorry to hear the news that Michael Basman, ‘by a very long way, the most creative chess player of his generation’ (William Hartston), has died.

He tied for first in the 1973 British championship, though lost the playoff match, played for England in the 1968 Olympiad, and became an IM in 1980, when opportunities for titles were much harder to come by. A comprehensive tribute (forwarded by John Griffin, for which many thanks) appeared at Chess.com, which had also recently featured a collection of his most notable games. These include his draws against Botvinnik, earning his praise, and Tal, in a game he could have won, and his ‘Immortal Waiting Game’ win against Ulf Andersson at Hastings 1974-75.

But he stood out for the extraordinarily provocative and eccentric openings he played. The St. George (1… a6) is perhaps the most famous, but more generally he pioneered what he called the ‘Creepy Crawly Opening’, avoiding the centre in favour of rook-pawn moves, e.g., 1. h3 and 2. a3. Examples of this with an Irish connection include his wins against Colm Daly and Niall Carton (British Championship 1990) and Mark Quinn (British Championship 1992).

These openings are far from double-edged, and usually did not lead to spectacular games. One exception was his win against Mel Ó Cinnéide in the Lloyds Bank Masters in 1993. This has come to light only relatively recently: it appeared in one of Basman’s opening books, and was added to the BritBase report on the event in July of last year, appearing in the games collection here shortly afterwards.

Basman - Ó Cinnéide, Lloyds Bank Masters 1993
Basman – Ó Cinnéide, Lloyds Bank Masters 1993
Position after 22… Qxc3

After a sharper then usual opening in these lines, Mel lost time with 12… Qa5?, and was lost a few moves later. In the diagrammed position, he has just played Q(d2)xc3, capturing a knight. The finish was 23. Rd7 Ng8 24. Rxb7 Qc1+ 25. Kh2 Qd2 26. Rb8+ Qd8 27. Rxd8+ Kxd8 28. Qf7 1-0.

[Click to replay the full game.]

Posted in Players | 1 Comment